08-31-04 20:18
No 528712
I found this article very interesting - do you think it can be extended to include knoevenagel condensations incolving nitroalkanes as well?
A Practical Knoevenagel Condensation Catalyzed by PEG400 and Anhydrous K2CO3 Without Solvent
Yu-Qing Cao, Zhi Dai, Rui Zhang, Bao-Hua Chen, Synth. Commun. 34(16), 2965-2971 (2004)
DOI:10.1081/SCC-200026650
Abstract
Knoevenagel condensation of aromatic aldehydes with active methylene compounds under solvent-free conditions to synthesize arylidene compounds in good to excellent yields using powdered anhydrous K2CO3 and PEG400 as catalysts has been described.
Introduction
Developing green chemistry is one of the most important purposes of organic synthesis at present. Organic synthesis in the absence of solvent is a powerful tool for the generation of structurally diverse molecules, due to their special selectivity, the ease of set-up and work-up, arousing great interest. (1–3) Moreover, solvent-free reactions sometimes are faster, taking just a few minutes rather than hours to complete because the reactants are close contact with each other. This aspect, coupled with the lower overall costs of running a reaction without solvent and no specially needed equipment, could become a decisive factor in industry.
Polyethylene glycols (PEGs) have been widely used as PTC in many organic reactions (4) (5) owing to their stability, low cost, environment-friendly, and easy availability. It has been proved that PEGs incorporating 7–9 units are more effective in catalyzing the reactions in which K+ or Na+ salts participate. (6) Especially, due to their liquid property and the two hydroxy groups, PEG 400–600 was more suitable for liquid–liquid or solid–liquid phase solvent-free organic reactions. As a continuance of our study, (7) (8) we take a primary investigation on using PEGs as PTC in condensation catalyzed by alkali without solvent.
Knoevenagel condensation of carbonyl compounds with active methylene compounds is one of the most important methods for the preparation of substituted alkenes. (9–11) Recently, Knoevenagel reaction under solvent-free conditions carried out by microwave irradiation and by grinding has rapidly increased. (12–14) But microwave irradiation process is difficult to apply in the industrial process until now and the grinding reaction is only suitable to some active solid reactants. We wish to report a convenient preparation of some arylidene derivatives by Knoevenagel condensation of aromatic aldehydes with active methylene compounds under solvent-free conditions using PEG400 and K2CO3 as catalysts (Sch. 1 ). The results are listed in Table 1 .
Results and Discussion
Anhydrous K2CO3 was more satisfied to obtain excellent yield in short time than other inorganic alkalies. KOH and NaOH were too strong bases to result in more by-products. KF and AcONa cannot catalyze effectively this reaction under the same conditions. Low yield was obtained and long reaction time is needed using MgO and CaO as base catalysts. Using K2CO3, KOH, KF, and MgO as catalyst for the condensation of benzaldehyde with ethyl cyanoacetate, a yield of 84%, 46%, 51%, and 55% was, respectively, obtained under the same reaction conditions. The appreciable amount of PEG400 was between 3 and 5 mol% to aromatic aldehydes. A longer reaction time will be necessary and lower yield obtained with less PEG. The more amount of PEG400 employed, the more products would be lost during the cause of washing with water.
From Table 1, it was shown that the condensation of aldehydes with electron withdrawing groups such as –Cl and –NO2 in the aromatic ring, with active methylene compounds can be carried out in relatively shorter time and higher yield than with electron donating groups such as –N(CH3)2 and –OCH3. A longer reaction time was necessary for the reactants with –OH owing to –OH can partly react with alkali to form salt and the reaction resulted in high melting point of the product. The rate would slow down along with increasing amount of the high melting point of products, so a high reaction temperature was needed. However, higher temperature will result in low yield especially for the products containing group –OH and ester bond due to the oxidation and hydrolysis of some reactant and product by water generating in reaction. But when nitromethane and nitroethane as active methylene compounds, arylidene compounds cannot be obtained under this condition.
In summary, this method was safe, environment-friendly, and working-up easily. The distinct advantages of this process lie in being easily practiced in industry without needing special equipment.
Experimental
TLC was GF254 thin layer chromatography with petroleum ether/diethyl ether (2/1) used as eluent. All the reagents and aromatic aldehydes were obtained from commercial suppliers and were not purified. Melting points were determined on a microscopy apparatus and uncorrected.
General Procedure
A mixture of aromatic aldehyde 2 (0.1 mol), active methylene compound 1 (0.1 mol), anhydrous K2CO3 (0.02 mol), and PEG-400 (1.5 mL) were taken into a 50 mL three-necked, round-bottomed flask equipped with mechanical stirrer and drying tube filled with KOH. The reaction was processed with vigorous stirring and heating at assigned temperature. The completion of the reaction was monitored by TLC. The reaction mixture was cooled to room temperature and treated with cool water (acidifying needed for the products with –OH). The product was filtered, dried, recrystallized from ethanol, and identified by comparison of physical data and 1H NMR and IR spectra with those described in the literatures.
The Hive - Clandestine Chemists Without Borders
(Heavyweight Chempion(eer))
09-01-04 04:09
No 528832
The author says no in the results and discussion area.
"But when nitromethane and nitroethane as active methylene compounds, arylidene compounds cannot be obtained under this condition."
I have another article in which they use ZnCl2 as catalyst but the reactants was also just a bunch of nitriles. Nitroalkanes are a special kind of critters. But they got some product with KF as base and this nitrile as reactant, which leads me to think that the reaction conditions can be tweaked to make this base useful for our purposes. It does obviously work to make nitroalcohols so we're half-way there. It is just a matter of dehydrate the nitroalcohols in a simple way. Of course the aim is to dehydrate them in situ so it becomes a one-pot reaction (condensation/dehydration). But I think it is doable.
Severe Aztecoholic and President of Sooty's fanclub - Sooty for President!!
(Chief Bee)
09-01-04 05:18
No 528712
I found this article very interesting - do you think it can be extended to include knoevenagel condensations incolving nitroalkanes as well?
A Practical Knoevenagel Condensation Catalyzed by PEG400 and Anhydrous K2CO3 Without Solvent
Yu-Qing Cao, Zhi Dai, Rui Zhang, Bao-Hua Chen, Synth. Commun. 34(16), 2965-2971 (2004)
DOI:10.1081/SCC-200026650
Abstract
Knoevenagel condensation of aromatic aldehydes with active methylene compounds under solvent-free conditions to synthesize arylidene compounds in good to excellent yields using powdered anhydrous K2CO3 and PEG400 as catalysts has been described.
Introduction
Developing green chemistry is one of the most important purposes of organic synthesis at present. Organic synthesis in the absence of solvent is a powerful tool for the generation of structurally diverse molecules, due to their special selectivity, the ease of set-up and work-up, arousing great interest. (1–3) Moreover, solvent-free reactions sometimes are faster, taking just a few minutes rather than hours to complete because the reactants are close contact with each other. This aspect, coupled with the lower overall costs of running a reaction without solvent and no specially needed equipment, could become a decisive factor in industry.
Polyethylene glycols (PEGs) have been widely used as PTC in many organic reactions (4) (5) owing to their stability, low cost, environment-friendly, and easy availability. It has been proved that PEGs incorporating 7–9 units are more effective in catalyzing the reactions in which K+ or Na+ salts participate. (6) Especially, due to their liquid property and the two hydroxy groups, PEG 400–600 was more suitable for liquid–liquid or solid–liquid phase solvent-free organic reactions. As a continuance of our study, (7) (8) we take a primary investigation on using PEGs as PTC in condensation catalyzed by alkali without solvent.
Knoevenagel condensation of carbonyl compounds with active methylene compounds is one of the most important methods for the preparation of substituted alkenes. (9–11) Recently, Knoevenagel reaction under solvent-free conditions carried out by microwave irradiation and by grinding has rapidly increased. (12–14) But microwave irradiation process is difficult to apply in the industrial process until now and the grinding reaction is only suitable to some active solid reactants. We wish to report a convenient preparation of some arylidene derivatives by Knoevenagel condensation of aromatic aldehydes with active methylene compounds under solvent-free conditions using PEG400 and K2CO3 as catalysts (Sch. 1 ). The results are listed in Table 1 .
Results and Discussion
Anhydrous K2CO3 was more satisfied to obtain excellent yield in short time than other inorganic alkalies. KOH and NaOH were too strong bases to result in more by-products. KF and AcONa cannot catalyze effectively this reaction under the same conditions. Low yield was obtained and long reaction time is needed using MgO and CaO as base catalysts. Using K2CO3, KOH, KF, and MgO as catalyst for the condensation of benzaldehyde with ethyl cyanoacetate, a yield of 84%, 46%, 51%, and 55% was, respectively, obtained under the same reaction conditions. The appreciable amount of PEG400 was between 3 and 5 mol% to aromatic aldehydes. A longer reaction time will be necessary and lower yield obtained with less PEG. The more amount of PEG400 employed, the more products would be lost during the cause of washing with water.
From Table 1, it was shown that the condensation of aldehydes with electron withdrawing groups such as –Cl and –NO2 in the aromatic ring, with active methylene compounds can be carried out in relatively shorter time and higher yield than with electron donating groups such as –N(CH3)2 and –OCH3. A longer reaction time was necessary for the reactants with –OH owing to –OH can partly react with alkali to form salt and the reaction resulted in high melting point of the product. The rate would slow down along with increasing amount of the high melting point of products, so a high reaction temperature was needed. However, higher temperature will result in low yield especially for the products containing group –OH and ester bond due to the oxidation and hydrolysis of some reactant and product by water generating in reaction. But when nitromethane and nitroethane as active methylene compounds, arylidene compounds cannot be obtained under this condition.
In summary, this method was safe, environment-friendly, and working-up easily. The distinct advantages of this process lie in being easily practiced in industry without needing special equipment.
Experimental
TLC was GF254 thin layer chromatography with petroleum ether/diethyl ether (2/1) used as eluent. All the reagents and aromatic aldehydes were obtained from commercial suppliers and were not purified. Melting points were determined on a microscopy apparatus and uncorrected.
General Procedure
A mixture of aromatic aldehyde 2 (0.1 mol), active methylene compound 1 (0.1 mol), anhydrous K2CO3 (0.02 mol), and PEG-400 (1.5 mL) were taken into a 50 mL three-necked, round-bottomed flask equipped with mechanical stirrer and drying tube filled with KOH. The reaction was processed with vigorous stirring and heating at assigned temperature. The completion of the reaction was monitored by TLC. The reaction mixture was cooled to room temperature and treated with cool water (acidifying needed for the products with –OH). The product was filtered, dried, recrystallized from ethanol, and identified by comparison of physical data and 1H NMR and IR spectra with those described in the literatures.
The Hive - Clandestine Chemists Without Borders
(Heavyweight Chempion(eer))
09-01-04 13:09
No 528832
The author says no in the results and discussion area.
"But when nitromethane and nitroethane as active methylene compounds, arylidene compounds cannot be obtained under this condition."
I have another article in which they use ZnCl2 as catalyst but the reactants was also just a bunch of nitriles. Nitroalkanes are a special kind of critters. But they got some product with KF as base and this nitrile as reactant, which leads me to think that the reaction conditions can be tweaked to make this base useful for our purposes. It does obviously work to make nitroalcohols so we're half-way there. It is just a matter of dehydrate the nitroalcohols in a simple way. Of course the aim is to dehydrate them in situ so it becomes a one-pot reaction (condensation/dehydration). But I think it is doable.
Severe Aztecoholic and President of Sooty's fanclub - Sooty for President!!
(Hive Bee)
09-01-04 16:33
No 528858
Knoevenagel reactions can be done without using additional solvent; just slap together aldehyde, nitroalkane and a carboxylic salt of an amine (butylamine, amylamine, ethylamine, ethylenediamine and methylamine work fine for example), add enuff silica beads or mol sieves to suck up any formed water, and there you go (stir until completion, then cool to get crystalline product).
No solvent - the nitroalkane acts both as solvent and reagent.
I fail to see the purpose behind using inorganic catalysts and claiming that "green chemistry" - the environment won't care whether if I use much ethanol or little PEG400, I promise you!!
(especially when the ethanol is recycled by distillation)- so: what's the point behind this solvent-free knoevenagel condensation?
"From alipathic aldehydes and the nitro compounds, L. Henry5 obtained nitroalkohols by using alkalies or their carbonates." 5): Compt. Rend. 120, 1265; 121/210 (1895); Chem.Ber. 28, ref. 606-774)
And the ZnCl2 knoevenagel reference is: Ann.d.Chem. 225, 321 (1884) (for the interested)
Greetz, A
Pleased to meet you hope you get my name.
But whats puzzlin you is the nature of my game!
(Heavyweight Chempion(eer))
09-03-04 14:04
No 529332
I fail to see the purpose behind using inorganic catalysts and claiming that "green chemistry" - the environment won't care whether if I use much ethanol or little PEG400, I promise you!! (especially when the ethanol is recycled by distillation)
Green chemistry is everybodys responsibility. But in this case it usually means the big boys producing multi-tons/day and normally uses 1,4-dioxane, chloroform, benzene or something equally nasty.
Severe Aztecoholic and President of Sooty's fanclub - Sooty for President!!