Magnesium/Hydrazinium Monoformate:
A new Hydrogenation System for the
Selective Reduction of Nitro Compounds

K. Abiraj, Shankare Gowda, D. Channe Gowda
Synth. React. Inorg. Met.-Org. Chem. 32(8), 1409-1417 (2002)

HTML by Rhodium

Abstract

The nitro group in aliphatic and aromatic nitro compounds, which also contain reducible substituents such as alkenes, nitriles, carboxylic acids, phenols, halogens, esters, etc., is selectively and rapidly reduced at room temperature to the corresponding amine in good yield by employing hydrazinium monoformate in the presence of magnesium powder. It was observed that, hydrazinium monoformate is more effective than hydrazine or formic acid or ammonium formate and reduction of the nitro group occurs without hydrogenolysis in the presence of low-cost magnesium compared to expensive metals like palladium, platinum, ruthenium, etc.

Introduction

Rapid and selective reduction of nitro compounds is of importance for the preparation of amines, particularly when a molecule contains other reducible moieties1-5. The synthesis and biological evaluation of aromatic amines are active and important areas of research and their chemistry by derivative formation has been widely studied6-7. Numerous new reagents have been developed for the reduction of aromatic nitro compounds8-9. Though some of these are widely used, they still have limitations based on safety and handling considerations10-12. To overcome these difficulties, several new methodologies have been developed13-14. However, little attention has been paid to the reduction of aliphatic nitro compounds15-17, which traditionally are reduced by high-pressure catalytic hydrogenation18-20. Many of these reduction methods also have substantial limitations with regard to chemoselectivity. For example, poor selectivity was reported in the reduction of aromatic nitro compounds, which have halogens, nitrile, carboxyl, hydroxyl, etc., as substituents. Reduction at reflux temperature11,21 for several hours can cause rearrangements and cyclization in polyfunctional nitro compounds. Therefore, we examined several methods to improve the reduction process, and, especially, to obtain selectivity over reducible or other labile substituents. In this context, the use of 5% platinum on carbon was found to be efficient but not cost effective22.

 

Results And Discussion

In this communication, we wish to report, a rapid and simple reduction of aliphatic and aromatic nitro compounds to the corresponding amino derivatives by using magnesium powder and hydrazinium monoformate, at room temperature [Eq. 1].

The reduction of nitro compounds in the presence of magnesium powder and hydrazinium monoformate is completed within one to ten minutes with the course of the reaction monitored by thin layer chromatography and IR spectra. No bands are observed for -N=N-, -NH-OH, -N=O moieties. The work-up and isolation of the products were easy and all the compounds reduced (Table 1) by this system were obtained in good yields (90–95%). The products were characterized by comparison of their TLC, IR spectra and melting points with authentic samples. Control experiments were carried out using a few of the nitro compounds with hydrazinium monoformate, but without magnesium powder, did not yield the desired products. In order to test the selectivity, reductions were attempted with p-dichlorobenzene, p-chloro-m-cresol, β-naphthol, cinnamic acid, acetanilide, benzoic acid, anisole, benzonitrile and phenyl acetate at laboratory temperature. However, these reactions failed to give any reduced product.

Table I
Magnesium Catalyzed Reduction of Nitro Compounds Using Hydrazinium Monoformate

Nitro Compound
Reaction Time
 Product
Yielda
Melting Point (°C)
Found
Lit.
o-Nitrophenol
2.5 min
o-Aminophenol
94%
173–175
174
m-Nitrophenol
2 min
m-Aminophenol
95%
121–123
123
o-Nitrotoluene
3 min
o-Toluidineb
92%
142–144
144
m-Nitrotoluene
2 min
m-Toluidineb
93%
124–126
125
p-Nitrotoluene
5 min
p-Toluidine
92%
44–45
45
α-Nitronaphthalene
2 min
α-Naphthylamine
92%
50–51
50
β-Nitronaphthalene
2 min
β-Naphthylamine
94%
111–113
113
o-Nitroanisole
3 min
o-Anisidineb
94%
58–60
60
m-Nitroanisole
2 min
m-Anisidinec
95%
81–82
80
p-Nitroanisole
3 min
p-Anisidine
95%
56–57
57
o-Nitroaniline
2.5 min
o-Phenylenediamine
93%
100–103
102
m-Nitroaniline
2 min
m-Phenylenediamine
94%
64–65
64
p-Nitroaniline
3 min
p-Phenylenediamine
94%
140–143
141
m-Nitrobenzyl alcohol
3 min
m-Aminobenzyl alcohol
91%
96–98
97
p-Nitrobenzamide
2.5 min
p-Aminobenzamide
92%
115–116
114
p-Nitrophenylacetate
2.5 min
p-Aminophenylacetatec
93%
148–151
150
o-Nitrobenzoic acid
5 min
o-Aminobenzoic acid
85%
144–147
145
o-Nitrochlorobenzene
0.5 min
o-Chloroanilineb
93%
99–100
99
m-Nitrochlorobenzene
0.5 min
m-Chloroanilineb
91%
120–123
122
p- Nitrochlorobenzene
0.5 min
p-Chloroaniline
93%
70–71
71
o-Nitrobromobenzene
1 min
o-Bromoanilineb
94%
115–117
116
m-Nitrobromobenzene
1 min
m-Bromoanilineb
94%
118–121
120
p-Nitrobromobenzene
1 min
p-Bromoaniline
93%
65–66
66
m-Nitroiodobenzene
2 min
m-Iodoaniline
92%
119–121
119
p-Nitrocinnamic acid
3 min
p-Aminocinnamic acidd
90%
265–268
265–270
p-Nitrobenzonitrile
2.5 min
p-Aminobenzonitrile
92%
84–85
83–85
p-Nitrophenylacetonitrile
2 min
p-Aminophenylacetonitrile
91%
45–48
45–48
p-Nitrophenethyl alcohol
2 min
p-Aminophenethyl alcohol
90%
108–111
108–110
p-Nitroacetanilide
2 min
p-Aminoacetanilide
94%
163–165
163
Methyl p-nitrocinnamate
3 min
Methyl p-aminocinnamate
90%
128–130
129
Nitromethane
1 min
Methylamined
75%
230–233
232–234
Nitroethane
1 min
 Ethylamined
77%
106–108
107–108
1-Nitropropane
1.5 min
 1-Aminopropaned
80%
158–160
160–162
1-Nitrobutane
2 min
 1-Aminobutanee
74%
78–80
78
  1. Isolated yields are based on a single experiment and the yields were not optimized.
  2. Isolated as benzoyl derivative.
  3. Isolated as acetyl derivative.
  4. Isolated as hydrochloride salt.
  5. Boiling point.

Several interesting features of the reduction reaction are apparent from Table I. First, electron-withdrawing substituents enhance the rate of reduction. The reduction of nitro compounds having electron-withdrawing substituents was completed within 1 min. On the other hand, electron-releasing groups slow the reaction rate. The degree of variation of reaction time depends on the position of the electron releasing substituents. Thus m-nitroaniline undergoes faster reduction than o-nitroaniline. The latter is reduced faster than p-nitroaniline.

 

Summary and Outlook

In summary, magnesium/hydrazinium monoformate provides a convenient system for the selective reduction of aliphatic and aromatic nitro compounds. The source of hydrogen for this catalytic transfer hydrogenation method is hydrazinium monoformate, a new hydrogen donor, which is inexpensive, more effective than either hydrazine or formic acid. Most of the reactions were completed within 2 min as monitored by the disappearance of the starting materials and concomitant formation of the product (TLC). This system is not helpful in obtaining directly an amino carbonyl compound, due to the formation of hydrazone derivatives with the donor.

Thus, the reduction of nitro compounds can be accomplished with magnesium powder instead of expensive platinum or palladium, etc., without affecting the other reducible or hydrogenolysable substituents. The yields are virtually quantitative and analytically pure products are obtained. The obvious advantages of the proposed method over previous methods are: (i) selective reduction of nitro compounds in the presence of other reducible or hydrogenolysable groups, (ii) easy procedure, (iii) rapid reduction, (iv) high yields of substituted amines, (v) avoidance of strong acid media, (vi) no requirement for pressure apparatus and (vii) inexpensive. This procedure, therefore, will be of general use, especially in cases where rapid, mild and selective reduction is required. Further investigations of other useful applications related to deblocking of protecting groups in peptide synthesis are in progress.

Experimental

Materials

All of the nitro compounds, hydrazine hydrate and formic acid were purchased from Aldrich Chemical Company (USA). The nitro compounds were recrystallized or distilled prior to use. Magnesium powder and 60-120-mesh silica gel (for column chromatography) were purchased from SISCO Research Laboratories Pvt. Ltd., Bombay (India). The magnesium was treated with 0.01N hydrochloric acid for about 2 min. It was then filtered through a sintered glass funnel and washed with water, dry methanol and dry ether. The thus obtained magnesium was vacuum dried and stored. All of the solvents used were analytical grade or were purified according to standard procedures. Thin layer chromatography was carried out on silica gel plates obtained from Whatman, Inc. The melting points were determined by a Thomas–Hoover melting point apparatus and are uncorrected. IR spectra were recorded on a Shimadzu FTIR-8300 spectrometer.

Typical Procedure

Hydrazinium monoformate was prepared by neutralizing slowly, equal moles of hydrazine hydrate and 85% formic acid (no solvent) in an ice water bath, with constant stirring. The obtained hydrazinium monoformate solution was used as such for the reductions. A suspension of an appropriate nitro compound (5 mmol) and magnesium powder (10 mmol) in methanol or in any other suitable solvent (5 mL) was stirred under nitrogen atmosphere with hydrazinium monoformate (2 mL) at room temperature. After the completion of the reaction (monitored by TLC), the catalyst was filtered off. The residue was extracted with 15 mL of chloroform or dichloromethane or diethyl ether. The extract was washed twice with 15 mL saturated sodium chloride solution and then with 10 mL water. The organic layer was dried (Na2SO4) and then evaporated to obtain the desired amino derivative.

In order to obtain good yield of volatile aliphatic amine, the reaction was carried out by the controlled addition of hydrazinium monoformate through a condenser cooled with ice water and by immersing the reaction flask in a cold-water bath. After filtration, the reaction mixture was neutralized with HCl. The solvent was evaporated under reduced pressure. The residue was lyophilized or subjected to column chromatography by using 60-120 mesh silica gel and a suitable eluting system (50:50 chloroform:benzene, 60:40 chloroform:benzene, 80:20 chloroform:benzene, 90:10 chloroform:benzene, 80:20 chloroform:methanol, 85:15 chloroform:methanol, 90:10 chloroform:methanol, 95:5 chloroform:methanol). Aliphatic amines were obtained as their hydrochloride salts in up to 80% yields.

References

  1. Ram S., Ehrenkaufer R.E., A General Procedure for Mild and Rapid Reduction of Aliphatic and Aromatic Nitro Compounds Using Ammonium Formate as a Catalytic Transfer Agent, Tetrahedron Lett. 25(32), 3415–3418 (1984)
  2. Yuste F., Saldana M., Walls F., Selective Reduction of Aromatic Nitro Compounds Containing O- and N-Benzyl Groups with Hydrazine and Raney Nickel, Tetrahedron Lett., 23 (2) , (1982) 147–148.
  3. Lyle R.E., LaMattina J.L., Selective Hydrogenation of 2,6-Dinitroanilines, Synthesis, (10) , (1974) 726–727.
  4. Ho T.L., Wang C.M., Reduction of Aromatic Nitro Compounds by Titanium(III) Chloride, Synthesis, (1) , (1974) 45.
  5. Onopchenko A., Sabourin E.T., Selwitz C.M., Selective Catalytic Hydrogenation of Aromatic Nitro Groups in the Presence of Acetylenes. Synthesis of (3-Aminophenyl)acetylene via Hydrogenation of (3-Nitrophenyl)acetylene over Cobalt Polysulfide and Ruthenium Sulfide Catalyst, J. Org. Chem., 44 (21) , (1979) 3671–3674.
  6. Askin D., Wallace M.A., Vacca J.P., Reamer R.A., Volante R.P., Shinkai I., Highly Diastereoselective Alkylation of Amide Enolates: New Route to Hydroxyethylene Dipeptide Isoster Inhibitors of HIV-1 Protease, J. Org. Chem., 57 (10) , (1992) 2771–2773.
  7. Ojima I., Kato K., Nakahashi K., Fuchikami T., Fujita M., New and Effective Routes to Fluoro Analogues of Aliphatic and Aromatic Amino Acids, J. Org. Chem., 54 (19) , (1989) 4511–4522.
  8. Baik W., Han J.L., Lee K.C., Lee N.H., Kim B.H., Hahn J.T., Selective Reduction of Aromatic Nitro Compounds to Aromatic Amines by Baker's Yeast in Basic Solution, Tetrahedron Lett., 35 (23) , (1994) 3965–3966.
  9. Mahdavi F., Bruton T.C., Li Y., Photoinduced Reduction of Nitro Compounds on Semiconductor Particles, J. Org. Chem., 58 (3) , (1993) 744–746.
  10. Greenspoon N., Keinan E., Selective Deoxygenation of Unsaturated Carbohydrates with Pd(0)/Ph2SiH2/ZnCl2. Total Synthesis of (+)-(S,S)-(6-Methyltetrahydropyran-2-yl)acetic Acid, J. Org. Chem., 53 (16) , (1988) 3723–3731.
  11. Johnstone R.A.W., Wilby A.H., Entwistle I.D., Heterogeneous Catalytic Transfer Hydrogenation and Its Relation to Other Methods for Reduction of Organic Compounds, Chem. Rev., 85 (1985) 129–170.
  12. Johnson H.E., Crosby D.G., N-Alkylation of Amides. A Novel Procedure, J. Org. Chem., 27 (1962) 2205.
  13. Banik B.K., Barakat K.J., Wagle D.R., Manhas M.S., Bose A.K., Microwave-Assisted Rapid and Simplified Hydrogenation, J. Org. Chem., 64 (16) , (1999) 5746–5753.
  14. Wiener H., Blum J., Sasson Y., Studies on the Mechanism of Transfer Hydrogenation of Nitroarenes by Formate Salts Catalysed by Pd/C, J. Org. Chem., 56, 4481–4486 (1991)
  15. Akita Y., Inaba M., Uchida H., Ohta A., Reduction of Some Nitro Compounds and Sulfoxides with Chromium(II) Chloride, Synthesis, (11) , (1977) 792–794.
  16. Borah H.N., Prajapati D., Sandhu J.S., Ghosh A.C., Bismuth(III) Chloride-Zinc Promoted Selective Reduction of Aromtic Nitro Compounds to Azoxy Compounds, Tetrahedron Lett., 35 (19) , (1994) 3167–3170.
  17. Ramos M.N., Srivastava R.M., Brito M.B., De Sa G.F., Configuration and Conformation of Benzamide O-(Anilinocarbonyl)oxime, J. Chem. Research (S), (7) , (1984) 228–229.
  18. George J., Chandrashekaran S., Selective Reduction of Nitro Compounds with Titanium(II) Reagents, Synth. Commun. 13(6), 495–500 (1983)
  19. Finkbeiner H.L., Stiles M., Chelation as a Driving Force in Organic Reactions. IV. Synthesis of -Nitro Acids by Control of the Carboxylation Decarboxylation Equillibrium, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 85 (5) , (1963) 616–622.
  20. Stiles M., Finkbeiner H.L., Chelation as a Driving Force in Synthesis. A New Route to α-Nitro Acids and α-Amino Acids, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 81 (2) , (1959) 505–506.
  21. Furst A., Berlo R.C., Hooton S., Hydrazine as a Reducing Agent for Organic Compounds (Catalytic Hydrazine Reductions), Chem. Rev., 65 (1965) 51–63.
  22. Gowda D.C., Mahesha B., Catalytic Transfer Hydrogenation of Aromatic Nitro Compounds by Employing Ammonium Formate and 5% Platinum on Carbon, Synth. Commun., 30 (20) , (2000) 3639–3644.