The Willgerodt Reaction
Phenylacetic Acid from Styrene/Acetophenone

by Rhodium
Amine
Yield
Morpholine
84%
n-Heptylamine
59%
Piperidine
58%
Cyclohexylamine
47%
Aniline
23%
n-Butylamine
12.5%
Diethanolamine
10.3%
Ethanolamine
3.5%

Introduction

The Willgerodt-Kindler reaction with morpholine transforms acetophenones and styrenes to phenylacetic acids, through the intermediate phenylacetothiomorpholide, which is hydrolyzed in acid or basic solution to the desired acid.

Other amines will also work instead of the somewhat watched morpholine, but the yields of the reaction will suffer, see the table to the right for the synthesis of phenylacetic acid from styrene using various amines1, the full experimental details are found below.

Experimental

Phenylacetic acid from Styrene1

A mixture of 104g styrene, 80g sulfur (2.5 eqv.) and morpholine (174 g) was refluxed two hours (internal temp rising to about 175°C). The cooled reaction mixture was taken up in chloroform (some sulfur remained undissolved) and the chloroform solution was washed successively with an equal volume of water, sufficient dilute hydrochloric acid to remove the excess morpholine, and finally with an equal volume of water. The solvent was removed under vacuum, and the residue of crude phenylthio-acetmorpholide was refluxed for ten hours with 1200 ml of 50% (by weight) sulfuric acid. The cooled hydrolysis mixture was extracted with three 500 ml portions of ether and the combined ethereal extract was washed with 100 ml of 12% caustic soda. The caustic wash was acidified with conc. HCl and then extracted three times with 300 ml portions of ether. Removal of the solvent from the combined ethereal extract gave 114g (84% yield) of nicely crystalline phenylacetic acid, m.p. 72-74°C.

One run in which the original reaction mixture was concentrated in vacuo on the steam bath and then hydrolyzed directly with 50% sulfuric acid gave only a 59% yield of phenylacetic acid, mp 71-74°C.

p-Methoxyphenylacetic acid2

Reflux a mixture of 42g of p-methoxyacetophenone, 13-15 g of sulphur and 30 g (30 mL) of morpholine for 5 hours. Pour the reaction mixture slowly into water, allowing the first addition to crystallise before the bulk of the mixture is added. Filter off the crude yellow solid, grind it up thoroughly with water, filter again and dry in the air. The yield of crude acetothiomorpholide, mp 65-67°C, is 68g. Recrystallisation from dilute methanol raises the mp to 71-72°C.

Add 50 g of the crude acetothiomorpholide to 400 ml of 10% alcoholic sodium hydroxide solution and reflux the mixture for 10 hours. Distil off most of the alcohol, add 100 mL of water to the residue, and strongly acidify the alkaline solution with hydrochloric acid. Cool, extract thrice with ether, dry the combined ether extracts, evaporate the solvent, and recrystallise the residue from water or dilute alcohol. The yield of p-methoxyphenylacetic acid, mp 85-86°C, is 26 g. A further quantity of acid may be obtained by extracting the mother liquors with ether.

3,4,5-trimethylphenylacetic acid4

A mixture of 48.6 g of 3,4,5-trimethylacetophenone, 39 g of redistilled morpholine, and 14.4 g of sulfur was reflused for 12 h. The warm reaction mixture was poured into 175 ml of hot ethanol and allowed to cool to permit the product to crystallize; yield, 62.6 g (79%) of 3,4,5-trimethylphenyl- acetothiomorpholide, mp 120-122°C, sufficiently pure for the next step. A sample recrystallized from ethanol melted at 123-124°C.

A mixture of 51 g of 3,4,5-trimethylphenylacetothiomorpholide, 110 ml of acetic acid, 16 ml of sulfuric acid, and 25 ml of water was heated under reflux for 5 hr and decanted from the small amount of tar formed into 850 ml of water with stirring. The precipitated crude product was collected, washed with water, and heated with 225 ml of 5% aqueous sodium hydroxide. Filtration from a small amount of insoluble matter and acidification with dilute hydrochloric acid gave 30 g (88%) of 3,4,5-trimethylphenylacetic acid sufficiently pure for the next step. A sample recrystallized from benzene-petroleum ether melted at 125-126°C.

Phenylacetic Acid from Acetophenone, using a PTC procedure5

Acetophenone (1.20 g, 10 mmol), sulfur (0.64 g, 20 mmol), morpholine (3 mL, 30 mmol), p-toluene sulfonic acid (0.06 g, 0.35 mmol) were added and held at reflux under constant stirring in an oil bath at 120–130°C for 8 h. After completion of the reaction as indicated by TLC, the reaction mixture was allowed to cool and 20% NaOH and triethyl benzyl ammonium chloride (TEBA) (114 mg, 0.05 mmol) were added to the reaction mixture and continued hydrolysis for further 8 h at 100°C. After completion of the reaction as indicated by TLC, the reaction mixture was cooled and filtered, the filtrate was acidified with HCl to pH 6 and then filtered off. The filtrate was further acidified to pH 2 and thus crude phenylacetic acid was obtained. The acid was then taken into 10% NaHCO3 solution and was washed with ethyl acetate (3x30 mL), separated the organic layer, and the aqueous layer was acidified with dilute HCl, to yield the pure phenylacetic acid as solid. In case of products from hydroxy acetophenones, the products were extracted into ethyl acetate. The dried organic layer was evaporated under reduced pressure to yield pure phenylacetic acid in 80% yield.

Morpholine From Diethanolamine3

2 moles of diethanolamine is placed in a flask with a thermometer and an air-cooled reflux condenser, and aqueous HCl is added until slightly acid. Heat rapidly to drive off all water, and keep the temperature at 200-210°C for 15h. Let cool, and add an excess of calcium oxide and dry distill the mixture. The distillate is first dried over NaOH pellets, then refluxed over small pieces of sodium for 30 min, and then fractionally distilled, bp 126-129°C. The yield is around 50% of theory.

References

  1. John A. King, Freeman H. McMillan, Studies on the Willgerodt Reaction. IV. The Preparation of Substituted Phenylacetic Acids, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 68, 2335 (1946)
  2. A. I. Vogel, Textbook of Practical Organic Chemistry, 3rd Ed, p. 925
  3. B.L. Hampton and C.B. Pollard, A New Synthesis of Morpholine, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 58, 2338 (1936)
  4. F. Benington, R.D. Morin, L.C. Clark, Jr., Mescaline Analogs. VII. 3,4,5-Trimethyl-Phenethylamine, J. Org. Chem. 22, 332-333 (1957)
  5. M. Mujahid Alam, S. R. Adapa, Facile Synthesis of Phenylacetic Acids via PTC Willgerodt-Kindler Reaction, Synth. Commun. 33, 59-63 (2003)